Other Treatments:

Cognitive-Behavioral Therapy

The goal of cognitive-behavioral therapy (CBT) is to regain control of reactions to stress and stimuli, thus reducing the feeling of helplessness that often accompanies anxiety disorders. CBT works on the principle that the thoughts that produce and maintain anxiety can be recognized and altered using various techniques that change behavioral responses and eliminate the anxiety reaction. Many studies have shown that a combination of CBT and medication works best for treating anxiety disorders.

A number of CBT approaches work well for treating many types of anxiety disorders. Studies suggest that CBT is also helpful for patients who have additional conditions, such as depression, a second anxiety disorder, or alcohol dependency. (It may take longer to achieve a successful outcome in such cases, however.) CBT is often given along with drug treatment. A study in the Journal of the American Medical Association found that children and adolescents with OCD responded better to CBT alone than the antidepressant setraline (Zoloft) alone, but most patients did best when they were treated with a combination of CBT and sertraline.

Both individual and group treatments work well. (However, people with social phobia may do better in individual sessions.) Several recent studies also indicate that telephone-based behavioral therapy works well for people with OCD, generalized anxiety disorder, and panic disorders.

Anxiety disorders are chronic, however, and recurrence is common. Some studies indicate that 30 - 82% of people with panic disorder and phobias have a recurrence of attacks at an average of 9 months, even after successful short-term therapy. Medications, then, are also generally recommended for most patients.

Basic Cognitive Therapy Techniques. Treatment usually takes about 12 - 20 weeks. The essential goal of cognitive therapy is to understand the realities of an anxiety-provoking situation and to respond to reality with new actions based on reasonable expectations.

• First, the patient must learn how to recognize anxious reactions and thoughts as they occur. One way of accomplishing this is by keeping a daily diary that reports the occurrences of anxiety attacks and any thoughts and events associated with them. A patient with OCD, for instance, may record repetitive thoughts.
• These entrenched and automatic reactions and thoughts must be challenged and understood. Again, using the OCD example, one approach is to record and play back the words of the repetitive thoughts, over exposing the patient to the thoughts and reducing their effect. One effective approach for patients with generalized anxiety disorder targets their intolerance of uncertainty and helps them develop methods to cope with it.
• Patients are usually given behavioral homework assignments to help them change their behavior. For example, a person with generalized social phobia may be asked to buy an item and then return it the next day. As the patient performs this action, they observe any unrealistic fears and thoughts triggered by such an event.
• As the patient continues with self-observation, they begin to perceive the false assumptions that underlie the anxiety. For example, OCD patients may learn to recognize that their heightened sense of responsibility for preventing harm in non-threatening situations is not necessary or even useful.
• At that point, the patient can begin substituting new ways of coping with the feared objects and situations.

Systematic Desensitization. Systematic desensitization is a specific technique that breaks the link between the anxiety-provoking stimulus and the anxiety response. This treatment requires the patient to gradually confront the object of fear. There are three main elements to the process:

• Relaxation training
• A list composed by the patient that prioritizes anxiety-inducing situations by degree of fear
• The desensitization procedure itself, confronting each item on the list, starting with the least stressful

This treatment is especially effective for simple phobias, social phobias, agoraphobia, and post-traumatic stress syndrome.

Exposure and Response Treatment. Exposure treatment purposefully generates anxiety by exposing the patient repeatedly to the feared object or situation, either literally or using imagination and visualization. It uses the most fearful stimulus first. (This differs from the desensitization process because it does not involve relaxation or a gradual approach to the source of anxiety.)

Exposure treatments are usually known as either flooding or graduated exposure:

• Flooding exposes the person to the anxiety-producing stimulus for as long as 1 - 2 hours.
• Graduated exposure gives the patient a greater degree of control over the length and frequency of exposures.

In both cases, the patient experiences the anxiety over and over until the stimulating event eventually loses its effect. Combining exposure with standard cognitive therapy may be particularly beneficial. This approach has helped certain patients in most anxiety disorder categories, including post-traumatic stress disorder.

Modeling Treatment. Phobias can often be treated successfully with modeling treatment:

• The therapy typically uses an actor who approaches an anxiety-producing object or engages in a fear-provoking activity that is similar to the patient's specific problem. Either a live or videotaped situation may be used, although the live model is considered to be more effective.
• The patient observes this event and tries to learn how to behave in a comparable manner.

Other Forms of Psychotherapy

Other forms of psychotherapy, commonly called emotion-based psychotherapy (EBT), psychodynamic therapy, or "talk" therapy, deal more with childhood roots of anxiety and usually, although not always, require longer treatments. They include interpersonal therapy, supportive psychotherapy, attention intervention, and psychoanalysis. All work is done during the sessions. Some research indicates that such therapies might be more useful for generalized anxiety, which may require more sustained work to process and recover from early traumas and fears. Studies suggest that although emotion-based psychotherapies are not as effective as cognitive-behavioral therapy (CBT) in treating panic disorders, patients tend to stay longer in EBT than in CBT. Some doctors suggest adding elements of EBT to the usual CBT and medication treatments.

Alternative Procedures

Anxiety Management Therapy. Anxiety management therapy is sometimes used as an alternative to CBT for generalized anxiety disorder. It involves patient education, relaxation training, and exposure to anxiety-provoking stimuli but does not include exercises in cognitive retraining.

Relaxation Training. Relaxation techniques use muscle relaxation and mental visualization to help focus attention towards a calming feeling. Some people find meditation helpful.

Breathing Retraining. Breathing retraining techniques may help reduce the physical effects of anxiety. For example, hyperventilation is one of the primary physical manifestations of panic disorders. This involves rapid, tense breathing, resulting in chest pain, dizziness, tingling of the mouth and fingers, muscle cramps, and even fainting. By practicing measured, controlled breathing at the onset of a panic attack, patients may be able to prevent full attacks.

Biofeedback. Biofeedback uses special sensors that allow patients to recognize anxiety states by changes in specific physical functions, such as changes in pulse rate, skin temperatures, and muscle tone. Eventually they learn to modify these changes, which in turn helps relieve anxiety. While commonly used, there are not many rigorous studies showing that biofeedback helps patients reduce or eliminate their symptoms over the long term.

Psychological Therapies for Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD)

Several types of psychological treatments have been designed specifically for treating patients with PTSD. These approaches include a special type of CBT known as trauma-focused cognitive behavioral therapy (TFCBT), and a psychotherapy treatment called eye movement desensitization and reprocessing (EMDR).

With TFCBT, patients are taught stress management skills. The therapist helps the patient develop a narrative (verbal, written, or artistic) about the traumatic event. Patients may be exposed to reminders about the trauma and are taught how to cope with future reminders. Through the process, the patient learns how to reprocess their thoughts, feelings, and behaviors.

With EMDR, the patient focuses on remembering the traumatic experience while visually following the rhythmic movement of the therapist’s fingers. The patient recounts to the therapist what memories have been provoked during the exercise. EMDR may help patients recall details and sensations that they had blocked out. Through this breakthrough, patients learn how to regain emotional control.

Transcranial Magnetic Stimulation and Other Neurostimulation

Transcranial magnetic stimulation (TMS) uses high frequency magnetic pulses to target and stimulate specific areas of the brain. Research has particularly focused on possible benefits for obsessive-compulsive behavior. Some studies have found some improvement in mood, but more research is needed to determine its value for reducing anxiety and obsessions.

In 2006, the U.S. National Institutes of Health funded a large study to examine whether deep brain stimulation (DBS) can help patients with OCD. DBS involves implanting tiny stimulators into the brain to block abnormal nerve signals that cause obsessive symptoms. These “brain pacemakers” are approved to treat epilepsy and Parkinson’s disease. Researchers hope that DBS may eventually provide a new treatment option for patients with severe OCD.

Surgery

A surgical technique called cingulotomy involves interrupting the cingulate gyrus, a bundle of nerve fibers in the front of the brain. It is sometimes used as a last resort for patients with severe OCD. A variation of this procedure using magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) to guide the surgeon has resulted in long-term improvement in about 25 - 33% of OCD patients in whom it is performed. The procedure is generally safe with few serious complications and does not affect intellect or memory.